Does your state do the “Dutch Reach?”

The League’s Bill Nesper was interviewed by National Public Radio about this subject. He was featured in a segment on All Things Considered. In this video on our YouTube channel, we address concerns cyclists have about where they can and should ride and how they can make themselves less likely to be struck by a vehicle door.

The Massachusetts Department of Transportation updated its Driver’s Manual this week to include information on the “Dutch Reach” — the practice of opening a door with the hand that is farther from the door when exiting a car. This practice helps people in cars make it a habit to look for approaching bicyclists and to open their door safely.

This is a great step by the DOT to provide accessible instruction on a technique that can reduce fatalities and serious injuries caused by dooring. The Dutch Reach Project, led by Michael Charney, is working to get all states to include similar information and ensure that all drivers understand this simple habit that improve safety. To learn more about the efforts of the Dutch Reach Project and how your state can update its driver’s manual go to https://www.dutchreach.org/.

Credit: Explanation of “Dutch Reach” from Chapter 4, p. 109 of the Massachusetts’ Driver’s Manual

Driver’s Manuals can be great resources for states to provide information to driver’s and provide information that can be used in driver instruction courses. Typically, the information in a Driver’s Manual is written for the laws of the state. However, Driver’s Manuals can also contain best practices that are legal, but not required. For instance, many states include information on safely passing a bicyclist even if there is not a 3 foot law and many other states address lane positioning with greater specificity than their state law.

If you’re interested in your state’s traffic laws, our Bike Law University series is a great place to learn more about them. Below is an updated version of our Bike Law University article on dooring, first published in 2015, and updated for Virginia’s dooring law which was passed in 2016.

BIKE LAW UNIVERSITY – DOORING LAWS

Dooring laws are laws that require people in a vehicle to open their door with a degree of care for moving traffic. A typical dooring law requires that a person opening a vehicle door ensure that it is reasonably safe to open the door, that opening the door will not interfere with moving traffic, and that the door is not open for any more time than necessary.

WHY SHOULD YOU CARE?

Dooring laws provide a relatively clear rule to assign responsibility to what some people might see as an unavoidable accident – an opened door hitting or being hit by passing traffic. These laws put the responsibility for opening vehicle doors on the person opening the door, rather than the people passing their vehicle. They provide a clear incentive for people to look for oncoming traffic — whether bikes, cars, or pedestrians — before opening their door. Without this type of law, bicyclists and other people in traffic have to show that they could not avoid an opening or opened door in order to recover for injuries caused by the open door.

“Dooring” collisions are likely one of the more common bicyclist-vehicle collision types, particularly in urban areas. Between 2010 and 2012, data from the City of Chicago showed dooring crashes making up between 7.3 and 19.7% of reported bicycle crashes. The Boston Cyclist Safety Report published in 2013 found that dooring crashes made up between 7 and 13% of all bicycle collisions in Boston between 2009 and 2012. Naturalistic studies, which rely on audio, video and telemetric data recorded about a bicyclist’s journey, point toward dooring threats being common as an Australian study found that unexpectedly opened vehicle doors accounted for 17.6% of bicyclist driver interactions.

However, more data on dooring would be appreciated, as an example, North Carolina, which has done a lot of work to crash-type its bicycle crashes, reports that only a handful of dooring crashes have been recorded each year from 2002 to 2012, for 20 total in that decade. A similar study from Wisconsin using the same crash-typing methodology found similarly low numbers of dooring crashes.

The prevalence of dooring crashes shows the need for dooring laws and public safety campaigns that promote them. In New York City, the LOOK! Campaign has served to remind people in vehicles to look before exiting, especially before opening cab doors. Chicago has adopted a similar campaign and recently raised fines for persons who open doors without looking.

The Model Minimum Uniform Crash Criteria, promoted by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Governors Highway Safety Administration and USDOT for law enforcement documentation of motor vehicle crashes, does not appear to include data elements that capture dooring. This may prevent more widespread understanding of the prevalence and dangers of dooring.

Some bicycling-related laws and bicycle infrastructure can contribute to dooring risks:

• Where to ride laws in some jurisdictions that require bicyclists to ride as far to the right as practicable without exceptions can be interpreted to require bicyclists to ride within the door zone, or justify why it is not “practicable” to ride within the door zone.
• Bicycle lanes can be striped so that they place bicyclists within the “door zone.” In certain jurisdictions, this can create the situation where a bicyclist is required by law to ride within the door zone. In some jurisdictions worries about bicycle lanes within the door zone have led to improved treatments that stripe the bicycle lanes outside the door zone and/or provide a hashed buffer to make bicyclists and motorists aware of the danger.

WHO HAS THEM?

Forty-one states have a dooring law. The nine states without a dooring law are: Connecticut, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Michigan, New Jersey, North Carolina, Tennessee and West Virginia. In thirty-eight states the dooring law applies to people leaving their door open longer than necessary to load or unload a passenger or cargo, as well as when a door is opened without caution.

Click here to view how your state stacks up

SPOTLIGHT STATE: RHODE ISLAND

The dooring law in Rhode Island has several notable characteristics that help bicyclists, pedestrians and motorists understand the intent of the law. Perhaps most notably, Rhode Island is one of only three states to specifically clarify that bicyclists and pedestrians are part of traffic. In many states the dooring law only references “traffic” leaving it up to interpretation or a reference to a definition found elsewhere in the vehicle code. Massachusetts, Rhode Island and Oregon clarify that bicyclists and pedestrians are protected by their dooring law. Rhode Island also clarifies that its dooring law applies to bicyclists and pedestrians on sidewalks, shoulders and bicycle lanes.

In addition to doing a great job of making sure that bicyclists and pedestrians are protected by its law, Rhode Island’s law reflects the most modern formulation of the UVC provision on dooring. This means that it applies to both sides of a vehicle and that it applies when doors are left open.

WHERE DID THEY COME FROM?

Dooring laws were introduced to the Uniform Vehicle Code in 1956 as UVC §11-1105. It was amended in 1962 and 1975, but has not been updated since 1975.